Menu Close

Shin Bet Chief Warns Administrative Detention Could Return as West Bank Settler Violence Intensifies

David Zini clashed with Settlements Minister Orit Strock during a cabinet meeting over attacks by Jewish extremists against Palestinians, warning that the Shin Bet could reconsider its previous opposition to administrative detention for Jewish suspects if other measures fail.

By Open Chronicle with agencies

Shin Bet chief David Zini has warned that Israel’s domestic security agency could seek the return of administrative detention for Jewish extremists accused of violence against Palestinians in the West Bank, marking a potential shift in his previous approach to the issue.

The warning reportedly came during a heated cabinet meeting on Sunday evening, when Zini clashed with Settlements and National Projects Minister Orit Strock over a series of attacks against Palestinian civilians and property.

According to Hebrew media reports, Strock accused the Shin Bet chief of presenting an unbalanced picture of violence in the West Bank, suggesting that Palestinians were being portrayed exclusively as victims while Jewish settlers were being blamed.

Zini responded sharply.

“The Palestinians do not burn the homes of Jews,” he reportedly told the minister.

A Heated Exchange Inside the Cabinet

The confrontation centered on increasing attacks by Jewish extremists against Palestinian communities in the West Bank.

Strock argued that leaders of the settlement movement had already condemned such violence and questioned what additional denunciations Zini expected.

“The entire settlement leadership opposes and condemns this kind of violence,” she was quoted as saying, adding that regional council leaders and rabbis had publicly spoken against the attacks.

Zini reportedly challenged Strock over whether she had personally condemned the violence.

She responded that she had done so repeatedly during appearances on Israeli radio.

The dispute highlighted growing tensions within the Israeli government and security establishment over how authorities should respond to extremist violence originating within the settler community.

Netanyahu and Sa’ar Warn of International Damage

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Foreign Minister Gideon Sa’ar also addressed the issue during the meeting, according to Israeli media reports.

Both reportedly argued that extremist attacks against Palestinians were damaging Israel’s international standing.

Zini then called for stronger and more visible condemnation from settlement leaders.

“We need to see condemnations and denunciations from the entire leadership,” he reportedly said. “This harms the settlement movement and harms security.”

The comments come as Israel faces increasing international criticism over violence against Palestinian civilians and property in the West Bank.

Administrative Detention Could Return

The most significant development from the meeting was Zini’s warning that administrative detention could once again be used against Jewish extremist suspects.

Administrative detention allows Israeli authorities to hold suspects without formally charging them, based largely on classified security information.

The measure has long been used against Palestinians but has also occasionally been applied to Jewish extremist suspects.

Earlier this year, Shin Bet field officers reportedly recommended administrative detention for several Jewish suspects following increased violence in the West Bank.

Zini declined to approve the recommendations at the time, according to Channel 13.

His position was consistent with Defense Minister Israel Katz, who had halted the use of administrative detention against Jewish suspects.

Sunday’s comments suggest that Zini may now be reconsidering that position.

According to the reports, he indicated that if conventional security measures proved insufficient to control Jewish extremist violence, he would demand that administrative detention be restored as an available tool.

A Shift in Zini’s Approach

Such a move would represent a significant evolution in Zini’s approach to Jewish extremism.

Earlier reporting by Haaretz indicated that Zini had questioned what he considered disproportionate treatment of Jewish suspects by Shin Bet investigators.

He was also reported to have described some settler attacks as “friction” rather than terrorism.

Security officials cited in previous Israeli reporting claimed that the Shin Bet division responsible for addressing right wing extremism had received less priority under his leadership.

His latest reported remarks therefore suggest that the growing scale of violence may be forcing a reassessment.

Olive Harvest Brings Renewed Tensions

The controversy comes during the annual Palestinian olive harvest, a period that has frequently produced confrontations around agricultural land in the West Bank.

Recent incidents have included attacks against Palestinian civilians, homes, vehicles and farmland.

In one incident in late September, two homes belonging to a Palestinian family in the West Bank village of Jalud were burned during an overnight attack attributed to Israeli settlers.

Such incidents have contributed to increasing international scrutiny of Israel’s handling of settler violence.

Netanyahu and other members of his government have previously argued that the attacks are carried out by a relatively small number of extremists and do not represent the broader settlement movement.

Zini’s comments nevertheless indicate that Israel’s domestic security agency increasingly views the violence as a security problem requiring stronger intervention.

A Sensitive Issue for Israel’s Security Establishment

How the Shin Bet handles Jewish extremism has long been politically sensitive.

The agency is responsible for protecting Israel against terrorism and internal security threats, placing it at the center of disputes over whether ideologically motivated attacks by Jewish extremists should be treated in the same way as other forms of political violence.

The debate has become particularly contentious within Israel’s current political environment, where parties closely associated with the settlement movement hold significant influence within the governing coalition.

Strock’s confrontation with Zini illustrates that divide.

For settlement advocates, broad characterizations of settler violence risk stigmatizing hundreds of thousands of Israelis living in the West Bank.

For security officials, repeated attacks against Palestinian civilians can create additional instability, provoke retaliation and damage Israel diplomatically.

Zini’s Leadership Under Scrutiny

Zini took over the Shin Bet following the departure of former director Ronen Bar after an extraordinary confrontation between Bar and Netanyahu.

Netanyahu said he had lost confidence in Bar following the Hamas led attack on southern Israel on October 7, 2023.

The cabinet subsequently voted to dismiss Bar, the first time an Israeli government had moved to remove a serving Shin Bet director.

Bar challenged the decision, arguing that political and personal considerations were involved.

Zini was subsequently approved to lead the agency.

His leadership has attracted scrutiny because of his religious background and reported views concerning the direction of the domestic intelligence service.

Now, the increase in settler violence presents one of the most politically difficult tests of his tenure.

Whether administrative detention is ultimately restored for Jewish extremist suspects will depend partly on whether the Shin Bet concludes that existing law enforcement and intelligence measures are sufficient.

Zini’s warning, however, suggests that an option he previously resisted is once again being considered as Israeli authorities confront escalating tensions in the West Bank.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Follow Open Chronicle on Mastodon